Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club and The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort fits your next getaway.
Best for families, couples, and golf lovers who want a polished Anguilla beach resort with two distinct beach areas, strong dining, a waterpark, and serious golf in a
Better for travelers who want villa-style accommodations in St. Maarten's Simpson Bay area with a more independent resort stay and easy access to the island's livelier vacation scene.
If you want the more complete luxury-resort experience—beaches, golf, spa, family facilities, multiple dining venues, and a quieter Anguilla setting—Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club is the stronger pick.
If your priority is a villa-style stay in St. Maarten with more of a self-directed, residential feel, The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort will likely feel more practical and flexible.
Bottom line: choose Aurora Anguilla for a full-service Anguilla resort with beaches, golf, spa, and family-friendly amenities; choose The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort for a more independent St. Maarten villa-resort base.
| Category | Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club | The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Upscale all-ages Anguilla resort with two beach areas, golf, spa, waterpark-style fun, and a polished family-and-couples atmosphere. | Villa-style St. Maarten resort experience in Simpson Bay, better suited to travelers who want more independence and a livelier island base. |
| Location | Set across Rendezvous Bay and Merrywing Bay in Anguilla, with a quieter beach-resort feel and access to the island's only golf course. | Located in Simpson Bay, St. Maarten, a more built-up and active vacation area than Aurora's Anguilla setting. |
| Rooms & Suites | Suite-focused accommodations across Rendezvous Bay and Merrywing Bay, with family-friendly options and remodeled sea-front suites noted on the serene Rendezvous side. | Villa-style accommodations, better for travelers who prefer a more residential setup over a classic luxury resort suite experience. |
| Dining | Six on-site restaurants and bars plus cafés and room service, with options ranging from beachfront dining to steakhouse, Japanese, and Mediterranean venues. | Better for guests who are comfortable mixing resort dining with the broader Simpson Bay restaurant scene rather than relying on a destination resort dining program. |
| Pools & Beach | Two white-sand beach areas, two outdoor pools, plus waterslide and lazy-river-style entertainment features on the active Merrywing side. | A Simpson Bay resort setting that suits travelers who want a St. Maarten beach base with a more active surrounding area. |
| Kids & Family | Children are welcome, and the resort actively supports family travel with facilities for kids, a family pool, waterpark features, and sports activities. | Can work for families who prefer villa-style space and a more independent St. Maarten stay, though Aurora has the clearer family-resort infrastructure. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who will use the full resort ecosystem: beaches, golf, spa, dining, waterpark features, and family activities. | Best value for travelers who want a villa-style base in Simpson Bay and plan to spend more time exploring St. Maarten independently. |
Accommodations at Aurora Anguilla are spread between Rendezvous Bay and Merrywing Bay, giving the resort two distinct personalities: a more serene beachside feel and a more active family-and-sports side.
Aurora is the better pick if you want a luxury resort suite experience tied to beaches, dining, golf, spa, and family amenities in one setting.
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort is the more natural choice if you prefer a villa-style stay in St. Maarten rather than a traditional Anguilla luxury resort layout.
If you want a more self-directed villa-resort setup, The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort has the edge; if you want the fuller resort campus, Aurora feels more complete.
Dining is a major advantage for Aurora Anguilla, with six on-site restaurants and bars plus cafés and room service. The lineup covers beachside meals, steakhouse dining, Japanese cuisine, Mediterranean flavors, pastries, cocktails, and in-room dining.
Expect:
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort is better framed as a St. Maarten base where the broader Simpson Bay area can be part of the dining experience, especially for travelers who like leaving the resort.
If on-property dining variety matters most, Aurora Anguilla is the clearer winner; if you plan to explore St. Maarten restaurants, The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort may suit you better.
Aurora Anguilla has the stronger beach-and-pool story, with accommodations spread across Rendezvous Bay and Merrywing Bay, two outdoor pools, and an entertainment park area with slides and a lazy river.
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort gives you a St. Maarten resort base in Simpson Bay, which is better for travelers who want a beach vacation tied to a busier island setting.
If you want the more scenic, self-contained beach-resort experience, Aurora Anguilla is the stronger choice; if you want Simpson Bay's livelier setting, choose The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort.
Aurora Anguilla is an all-ages resort and clearly supports family travel, with children welcome, family-oriented accommodations, waterpark features, sports activities, and a dedicated family-resort positioning.
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort can suit families who want a villa-style St. Maarten stay, especially if independence and space matter more than a large programmed resort environment.
If family-friendly resort infrastructure is a priority, Aurora Anguilla is the better fit; if your family prefers a more independent Simpson Bay base, The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort can make sense.
Aurora Anguilla offers the most value when you'll use its full resort footprint: two beach areas, golf, spa, dining, pools, waterpark-style amenities, and sports facilities.
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort is the better value if you mainly want a villa-style base in St. Maarten and do not need Aurora's golf, spa, waterpark, and destination-resort scale.
Choose Aurora if you want the more complete luxury resort: two Anguilla beach areas, golf, spa, dining variety, pools, waterpark-style amenities, and an all-ages atmosphere that works for both couples and families.
The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort is the better pick for travelers who want a villa-style St. Maarten base in Simpson Bay and a vacation that feels more independent and flexible.
For families, golfers, spa-focused travelers, and beach lovers who want more on-property depth, Aurora Anguilla is the stronger overall choice.
If you prefer St. Maarten over Anguilla, want a livelier surrounding area, and like the idea of villa-style accommodations, The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort is the more natural fit.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club:
